Used Subaru Forester for Sale Near Saugerties, NY Under $20,000 | Cars.com (2024)

Prequalify now

It only takes a couple minutes and won't affect your credit.

Prequalify now

It only takes a couple minutes and won't affect your credit.

Subaru of Troy

Romeo Nissan

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

Great vehicle

I have owned my 2017 Forester since late 2016. Except for normal maintenance I've had no problems with thr vehicle. All of the warning systems work very well,they have saved me from accidents numerous times. The automatic seat repositioning when some one else has used my is really handy eliminates all the adjusting needed to get the position back to my needs. Traction and controll during winter and bad weather are excellent. My forrester get used like a truck at times. Great overall car.

Romeo Nissan

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i review

Excellent choice!

Bought this car three years old with less than 50K miles on it. I’ve loved it since we got it. It has been very reliable, fun to drive, with pretty minor drawbacks. For example the maintenance has been very minimal. I haven’t noticed ANY oil burning or leaking (I have personally changed the oil every 3-4K miles). Sometimes on long trips it will burn some oil and need a top off, which the car alerts us to. Overall I’d buy this car over and over as long as it fit my needs at the time. Currently looking into an Ascent for future hockey trips and other trips.

Ruge's Automotive Inc.

Ruge's Automotive Inc. review

My new Forester XT touring

Was shopping for a Forester base but ended up with a Forester XT touring instead. Jennifer Mears was great she got me a great price and gave me an extensive test drive. Paul was very meticulous about the warranty and helpful add ons. I got the 0% financing. I wanted more on my trade but they will work with you! Great neighborhood too very nostalgic with great restaurants.

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

Love my forester

2018 forester 105000 miles it's smooth, quiet and very reliable it's needed nothing but a rear wheel bearing and oil changes. Has great visibility and drives really nice the gas pedal is a little touchy, and it sips gas I ave 30mph in winter and 34mph in summer

Abeel Auto Sales

Abeel Auto Sales review

Great dealership

Great car great customer service I have nothing to say bad at all would highly recommend!!! Even works good with people who don’t have great credit

2014 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

Great for family and pet owners

I was between a rock and a hard place after my Honda passed away-it drove itself to its demise due to the handbrake not on tight enough. So I had nothing to trade, no leverage. I know Subarus owned many Outbacks and they go forever. The problem is I'm 5' tall and this car is too big for me after the Honda and a Miata I have. I had 2 big dogs and felt the car would be great for a dog owner. Which it is. One dog rode on the back seat (covered) the other had the back to herself. Great for a dog owner. If you need a crate there's plenty of room. This would be a great vehicle for a children or pet family. I only have one 10 yr old dog left and this uses too much gas for me to consider a practical vehicle.

Ruge's Automotive Inc.

Ruge's Automotive Inc. review

Remote start installation

I received a phone call that vehicle was done. It was done on time, and the service manager was helpful answering some questions about future services for my new truck.

2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium review

Very reliable for the 2010 2.

Very reliable for the 2010 2.5 limited I bought used in 2023 with 196k miles. very sporty feel and look, quick response and the automatic was quiet even when pushed, acceleration on the base engine was awesome and driving was lots of fun. the leather seats are incredible although the lack of dual zone as an option was disappointing. The brakes were somewhat uninspiring but got the job done, and the steering feel and moonroof were awesome. Gas mileage is decent even in 2024 but was somewhat low in comparison to the 2010 outback at 22 city and 27 highway, at 17 city and 21 highwayI for the forester 2010 . I got in a high speed accident and cabin intrusion was non existent and all occupants got out uninjured. Best car I've ever had, would buy over any other Subaru new or used.

Ruge's Automotive Inc.

Ruge's Automotive Inc. review

Having your car serviced at the dealership

The service writers are actually your friends if you listen to them. The mechanics are very good and find trouble spots that need attention. It is your decision after all, listen and make the right one.

2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X review

I’m the 3rd owner of a 2012 Subaru Forester purchased at

I’m the 3rd owner of a 2012 Subaru Forester purchased at approx 175,000 miles and it still runs pretty good! It does burn oil up pretty quickly and mine has issues with reading the levels and won’t give me a warning light so i check the dip stick often. Mine did have exhaust issues and had to replace a rested out piping from the cat back, but mufflers were still good. Also the Oxygen sensor was a problem for awhile, which you can only use on brand for it to work properly. Gas mileage is decent for the size of the vehicle and its age. Only wish the front seats went back more bc my taller girlfriend who is 5’11 with long legs struggles to fit and be comfortable in the passenger seat.

Abeel Auto Sales

Abeel Auto Sales review

Highly recommended

I purchased a couple of cars from this dealership over the years and I am very satisfied with the Cars I purchased. I received them in a timely manner. Everyone was friendly and cars were clean and maintained

2018 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

2018 Forester

10/29/20222 wks ago i bought 2018 forester premium. Overall very happy with the vehicle. It feels solid for a small car.The drivers seat is very comfortable for me. Im 6"0 and weight 230lbs. My only complaint so far is freeway driving. Seems to wander alot and if on grooved payment with wind then it becomes a chore to drive.

All Motor Cars

All Motor Cars review

I am beyond grateful for Andrew and All Motor Cars for

I am beyond grateful for Andrew and All Motor Cars for giving me the chance to own a good quality car at a truly reasonable price. I love Subarus, and their selection is fantastic. Honestly, AMC was my first stop in what I thought was going to be a dreadful all day car shopping horror show (in below freezing temps!)...but we never made it past Tillson. Thanks, Andrew!! We can't wait to have so many adventures in Bertha!

2006 Subaru Forester 2.5 X review

Love my Subaru!

My only Osijek so far is I bought it so I’d have room to put my grandchildren’s car seat in back. Very little leg room for them

All Motor Cars

All Motor Cars review

This place is excellent.

This place is excellent. The best place to buy a used Subaru around. Andrew is helpful and we were happy with our vehicle.

2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Limited review

Dependable AWD

Have a 2009 with 110K miles on it. Very dependable. Averaging 25.8 MPG right now- not too bad for older AWD. I do drive the speed limit and accelerate probably slower than most, and brake easy. Only averaged 24 or so on the Oregon 101 by ocean- hilly, curvy and logging trucks on my butt. Good car. Don't miss my big has guzzler at all!!

All Motor Cars

All Motor Cars review

A great place for a pre-owned and fully service truck.

A great place for a pre-owned and fully service truck.. we bought a Toyota Tacoma a month ago after a friend recommended we go to All Motor Cars

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i review

Better than my Lexus

I bought this car in 2014...best car I ever owned. Have only replaced tires and am about to replace brakes. Now my husband wants one too.

All Motor Cars

All Motor Cars review

I've been buying used cars for the last 31 years.

I've been buying used cars for the last 31 years. The latest was a 2007 Subaru Outback wagon from All Motor Cars. Patchen and Andrew recommended several cars beyond those that were of interest to me. I was able to test drive them all. After choosing one, it was given a final prep by the mechanics in the on-site shop. Same day service. Best overall experience buying a used car. Thorough, professional, and honest. I'll do business with them again.

2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X review

Our third Subaru.

We love Subaru cars. We recently purchased an Ascent in the last week and went back to Subaru because we have been very satisfied. The Two Foresters we have owned and a previous purchase of a Tribeca have made us life time Subaru owners

All Motor Cars

All Motor Cars review

Thanks Frank for the fast and affordable repair on my

Thanks Frank for the fast and affordable repair on my daughter Leslie's Subaru. What a great job!!And great price..Thanks to Andrew and Pachin as well!!

2005 Subaru Forester 2.5 XS review

Best Subaru Ever!

I bought this vehicle brand new for my 50th, and yes, it almost has a personality. I trust my Subaru unconditionally and I plan to drive for many more years.

All Motor Cars

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i review

Best car I’ve ever owned.

Perfect for short people!! Great visibility with minimal blind spots. Reliable. Safe. Holds its value. Bought from Joe at Salton Motors. Excellent experience. I won’t own anything else. Great car.

All Motor Cars

2007 Subaru Forester 2.5 X review

Reliable and fun to drive

Bought one in 2010 with 32k miles on it. Head gasket failed at 110k. Thwy are known for this failure. $1000 repair including timing belt and water pump. Used an after market gasket. Car continued another 124k miles with regular service/oil changes/tires/brakes. Best car ever. Would still have it if it hadn't been rear ended and totaled on the highway. Car saved my life.

All Motor Cars

2010 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Limited review

Very enjoyable ownerships so far.

Original owner, drive for 10 years and 160k miles.With timely maintenance and regular oil changes every 5k miles had no issues with the car what so ever with very few minor anoences. 1. The car will trigger check Engine light if the gas cap is not sealed correctly. Had to check after every fill-up but the first several times was scarry. AC is week. In a heat wave you will sweat a little. Non turbo models fell slightly underpowerd. Not a big issue but you can feel it at times. Other than that I love the car. Spacious and roomy. Good visibility and AWD system you can not beat.

Mag Auto Corp

Mag Auto Corp review

Friendly staff

Excellent customer service. They made every step of purchasing my vehicle easy and enjoyable. Best car buying experience I’ve ever had. I would highly recommend. I have had my BMW for about three months now and I absolutely love it!

2019 Subaru Forester Sport review

Happy Demanding Customer

I’ve driven the Forester before and have been wanting one for two years. So now that it was time for me to give up my 2010 Legacy with 222,000 miles on it, I chose the Forester. The dealer is very customer friendly and very competitive in their pricing, even though I paid 25K plus for a four year old car…vestiges of the used car pandemic pricing. The car drives beautifully, smooth and quiet. I am very happy with my purchase.

Mag Auto Corp

Mag Auto Corp review

Dodge

They were so sweet and kind to us. Although we were unable to purchase a car here, I would recommend them to everyone!! Thank you!!

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

I love Subaru

This car was very comfortable and dependable. We had no issues with it. It has a little road noise issue but not too bad. We really enjoyed owning this car.

Mag Auto Corp

Mag Auto Corp review

Poppy is great!

Poppy was great to buy from. Was shopping for my first car. Found an awesome car through cars.com and we called him. Took it for a test drive, before which he had already put new tires and breaks on the vehicle. AC had issues, he got it fixed by a repair shop in 2 days, and picked it up shortly after. Car has a few cosmetic issues but he didn't try to hide them. Car came with a warranty which is great for peace of mind, but keep in mind not all of his cars do. He gave us a great deal, and I couldn't be happier.

2017 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

2017 Subaru Forrester

Had this car for seven years, never any problems, very low mileage. Very nice to drive, smooth gas mileage around 30 mpg. Traded it in for a new forester, I actually was ready to cry, when I left it. Very reliable.

Mag Auto Corp

Mag Auto Corp review

Fantastic!!

Fantastic!!! Very Cooperative people, good prices clean vehicles. I love my new purchase. I ill be sending all my family and friends Thanks MAG Auto.

2016 Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium review

In love with this vehicle

I've never owned a Subaru before but after purchasing the Forester, I may never own anything but a Subaru again! I love the Eyesight Drivers Assistant that it came equipped with. I can see why this car has one of the best safety ratings out there. The interior is very open, spacious, & comfortable and the panoramic sunroof is amazing! It drives and handles like a dream. I would recommend this car to anyone. You won't be disappointed!

Mag Auto Corp

Mag Auto Corp review

Poppy saved me!

Poppy at Mag Auto made my car-purchase an enjoyable and relieving experience. After being in an accident and obtaining medical injuries as well as a totaled previous vehicle, I was at a total loss and very much in need of a vehicle IMMEDIATELY. Poppy went out of his way to ensure I was in the vehicle within 24 hours of receiving all necessary documentation, made it a quick a painless process and ultimately sold me a car I immediately fell in love with. Thank you Poppy!!!!Maria, BMW X3

2013 Subaru Forester 2.5X review

I bought my Subaru in 2023 because it only had 60,000

I bought my Subaru in 2023 because it only had 60,000 miles on the OD. It's the minimal 2.5X model, but I couldn't pass up the car at such a low price. After driving it for over a year, I put only 6000 miles on it. I took it to the Subaru dealer for NY state inspection, and had the brakes replaced, and paid for the 60000 mi Subaru recommended service. I love this car, especially since I can connect my iPod to the blue tooth and play my music library. It is a bit noisy on the highway, but it's not the luxury model, so that's expected. The Subaru dealer said everything on the car was real solid. So far it has been very dependable, and easy to drive in the snow. It has no leaks, no dents, no squeaks, no problems. I've owned and driven 8 Subaru's over the past 40 years, and I'm hoping to keep my 2013 model and drive it for at least another 10 years.